Q1
What is your Illinois roofing license number, and can I verify it right now?
Why it matters
Illinois requires every roofing contractor to hold an active state license issued by IDFPR. The number is public record and takes about a minute to check at idfpr.illinois.gov. A contractor who cannot hand you the number while standing in front of you is telling you something useful.
What a straight answer sounds like
A number, given immediately, that matches the company name on your contract.
Our answer: Illinois Roofing License No. 104.010248 (Unlimited), printed on every proposal we issue. For work inside the city we also hold Chicago General Contractor License Class E No. TGC147129. Both are public, both are current, and you are welcome to check either before you call us back.
Red flag: An out-of-state license, a “corporate license” that does not exist in Illinois, a number registered to a different company, or “I will get that to you tomorrow.”
Q2
Will you waive my insurance deductible?
Why it matters
If the answer is yes, end the conversation. Waiving a deductible is insurance fraud under Illinois law (215 ILCS 5/155.22) and it breaches essentially every homeowner policy. The contractor is the one who benefits, and you are the one named on the claim if the carrier audits it.
What a straight answer sounds like
A flat no, with the reason attached.
Our answer: No. We do not waive, rebate, absorb or work around a deductible on any job, for any carrier, and we will tell you why on the first call.
Red flag: “We will take care of your deductible,” “we have a relationship with the carrier,” “you will not pay anything out of pocket.” One practice, several phrasings.
Q3
Will I be asked to sign an Assignment of Benefits?
Why it matters
An AOB transfers your insurance rights to the contractor. They then control communication with your carrier, negotiate the scope of the claim, and receive the payment directly. Disputes get settled between the contractor and the insurance company with you outside the room.
What a straight answer sounds like
No AOB, and no resistance when you decline one.
Our answer: We never ask for an AOB. You keep control of your claim, your carrier pays you, and you pay us against the proposal you signed.
Red flag: An AOB bundled into the contract packet, or a signature requested “just so we can speak to your adjuster.”
Q4
Does the written proposal list the work line by line, or is it one price?
Why it matters
A single number hides the scope, and scope is where roofs are won and lost. A real proposal says what comes off, what goes back on, where the ice-and-water shield goes, which flashings are replaced and what happens to the debris. Anything not written down before you sign is not promised.
What a straight answer sounds like
A page you can read start to finish, and tick off as the work happens.
Our answer: Our replacement proposals itemize it: tear-off down to the roof deck, where ice-and-water shield goes, the underlayment type, the exact shingle, each vent, each flashing location by name, and debris removal on completion. Residential and commercial alike.
Red flag: One line and a total, a refusal to itemize, or “it is all standard, do not worry about the details.”
Q5
What exact shingle are you installing, by brand and product line?
Why it matters
“Architectural shingles” is not a product. The brand and the specific line decide the wind rating, the impact rating, the warranty tier and how long the roof actually lasts. A contractor who will not name it keeps the option of substituting whatever is cheapest on delivery day.
What a straight answer sounds like
A manufacturer and a named product line, written into the proposal rather than described out loud.
Our answer: We name it in writing, for example GAF Timberline HDZ, and what is written is what goes on the roof. If you want to compare lines or step up to a premium material, we will price the alternatives rather than talk you out of them.
Red flag: “Name brand,” “premium architectural,” “contractor grade,” or a manufacturer named with no product line behind it.
Q6
If you find rotten decking under the shingles, what happens, and what will it cost?
Why it matters
This is the most common surprise charge in roofing. Nobody can see the deck until the shingles come off, so the honest move is to agree the price of that discovery before the job starts, not once a crew is already standing on your roof and the old shingles are in a dumpster.
What a straight answer sounds like
A rate agreed in advance, billed on the actual quantity, measured where you can see it.
Our answer: The proposal states the board replacement rate before we start, and you are billed on actual quantity used. No change order gets negotiated from the top of a ladder.
Red flag: No answer, “we will let you know if we find anything,” or a lump-sum decking allowance with no rate and no measurement behind it.
Q7
Who pulls the building permit, and is the cost inside this price?
Why it matters
A permit means somebody other than your contractor inspects the work. A contractor who asks the homeowner to pull it is often staying off the record, and it moves the liability onto you. Where a permit is required, it belongs in the price rather than in a footnote.
What a straight answer sounds like
The contractor pulls it, and the proposal states plainly whether the fee is included.
Our answer: We obtain the permit where one is required and the proposal says the cost is included. We also carry the municipal registrations and bonds that individual villages ask for before they will issue one.
Red flag: “Permit fees may apply,” a request that you pull it in your own name, or a suggestion that the job is small enough to skip one.
Q8
What is the workmanship warranty, and what document will I be holding at the end?
Why it matters
The manufacturer warranty covers defective shingles. The workmanship warranty covers the installation, which is where the majority of roof problems actually originate. A promise nobody can produce on paper is not a warranty, it is a conversation.
What a straight answer sounds like
A specific term, and a document issued to you when the job closes.
Our answer: Ten years on workmanship. You receive a signed warranty certificate in your close-out packet at completion, together with photographs of the finished work, so the cover is a document in your file rather than something you have to remember being told.
Red flag: A “lifetime” warranty from a company two years old, nothing in writing at all, or a term that only ever gets spoken aloud.
Q9
How long have you worked in this area, under this name?
Why it matters
The roofer you want is the one still answering the phone in ten years when something needs a second look. Years in business under one unchanged name is the cheapest proxy available for whether a warranty will mean anything when you need it.
What a straight answer sounds like
A number of years, a local address, and the same company name on the license, the proposal and the invoice.
Our answer: Leaders Roofing Corp has worked out of Mount Prospect since 1996, family-owned, same name for 30 years, residential and commercial. We work in Polish and English, which matters more often in this market than people expect.
Red flag: A company that appeared in your neighborhood within days of a storm, a brand-new entity name on an old pitch, or out-of-state plates with no local address to write down.
Q10
How long is this price good for, and is there a discount for signing today?
Why it matters
Honest pricing carries a date because material costs move. Pressure pricing carries a clock because the contractor needs your signature before you get a second opinion. They look similar on a doorstep and they are opposite things.
What a straight answer sounds like
A written validity period, and no penalty for taking the time to compare.
Our answer: Our proposals are valid for fourteen days, stated in writing on the document. There is no sign-today discount, because there is nothing a rushed signature protects you from.
Red flag: “This price is only good while I am here,” a discount that expires in your driveway, or a number that drops sharply the moment you hesitate.