About
Services
Roof Replacement Roof Repair Emergency Repair & Tarping Ice Dam Leak Repair Hail Damage Replacement Cedar Shake Slate Copper Roofing & Flashing Estate Home Roofing Commercial Roofing Flat Roofing Commercial Leak Repair Commercial Maintenance Roof Inspection Gutters & Siding Roof Coatings Gravel & Ballast Removal Sheet Metal & Flashing Church Roofing Why Choose Us Financing
Service Areas Our Work Blog Contact Careers · We're Hiring Polski / Po polsku
Get a Free Estimate Call 24/7 · (708) 847-5418
← Back to blog
November 14, 2026

Replacing a Clay Tile Roof With Brava Spanish Barrel Tile

Spanish Colonial Revival and Mediterranean homes around Chicagoland were built with clay barrel tile. When that roof finally has to come off, composite barrel is often the only practical match.

The houses this is about

Chicagoland has a scattering of Spanish Colonial Revival and Mediterranean-style homes from the 1920s onward, plus newer homes built to look that way, roofed in clay barrel tile. Clay can last a very long time, but not forever in a freeze-thaw climate, and the roofs we see have usually reached the point where broken tiles, failed underlayment beneath the tile and repeated patching make repair a losing game. Our tile roof lifespan and repair guide covers how to tell which side of that line you are on.

Why the replacement choice narrows quickly

If the house was designed around barrel tile, a flat shingle or a slate profile changes its character completely. Most composite manufacturers do not make a barrel profile at all, so the decision often comes down to new clay or Brava's Spanish barrel tile. That is a choice by elimination, which is why it is worth understanding both properly.

What composite barrel changes

Weight is the first difference. Clay barrel is heavy, and some older framing has been carrying it with less margin than anyone would design today; a composite barrel tile weighs a fraction of that. Breakage is the second. Clay cracks under foot traffic and in hail, which makes every repair or gutter job on a clay roof a risk; Brava's premium profiles carry a Class 4 impact rating under UL 2218. The third is maintenance: color runs through the full thickness of the composite tile, so a chip does not expose a different color underneath.

When new clay is still the right call

On a documented historic home, or where a board or a preservation review requires original materials, new clay may be the only acceptable answer. Some owners simply want the real material. Clay remains a legitimate, long-lived roof when it is installed over a modern underlayment with proper flashing. We will tell you which way we would go on your house and why.

The details that make a barrel roof look right

Barrel roofs live or die on their edges: the bird-stop at the eaves, the hip and ridge treatment, the rake finish and how the tile meets walls and chimneys. The underlayment matters even more than on a shingle roof, because water that gets under barrel tile is meant to be shed by the layer beneath. We specify a self-adhered membrane at the eaves and valleys and a full high-temperature underlayment where the pitch calls for it.

Salvaging original clay

Where some original tiles are sound, they can be salvaged for repairs on outbuildings or a garage, or kept as spares for a section that stays in clay. Whether that is worth the labor depends on how many tiles survive the removal, which we assess before the job, not after.

Approvals and timeline

If the home is in an HOA or a review district, plan time for the board to see samples. We prepare the submittal with the product data, full-size samples and a written description of the trim details. The Brava roof tile page covers the product and our certification.

Frequently asked questions

Does a composite barrel roof need structural reinforcement like clay?

Usually not. Composite barrel weighs a fraction of clay, so it typically does not need the structural review a new clay roof might. We still look at the framing from the attic before quoting.

Can you repair my clay tile roof instead?

Often, if the underlayment is still sound and the damage is limited to broken tiles or flashing. If the underlayment beneath the tile has failed across the roof, repairs only move the leak, and replacement is the honest recommendation.

What does a Brava barrel roof cost?

We do not publish a total for premium materials, because size, pitch, trim footage and deck condition vary too much between houses. Every estimate is written and itemized after we inspect the roof.

Let's talk about your roof.

No pressure, no obligation. Just a straight answer about what your property needs.

Request a Free Estimate Call 24/7 · (708) 847-5418
Call 24/7 · (708) 847-5418