About
Services
Roof Replacement Roof Repair Emergency Repair & Tarping Ice Dam Leak Repair Hail Damage Replacement Cedar Shake Slate Copper Roofing & Flashing Estate Home Roofing Commercial Roofing Flat Roofing Commercial Leak Repair Commercial Maintenance Roof Inspection Gutters & Siding Roof Coatings Gravel & Ballast Removal Sheet Metal & Flashing Church Roofing Why Choose Us Financing
Service Areas Our Work Blog Contact Careers · We're Hiring Polski / Po polsku
Get a Free Estimate Call 24/7 · (708) 847-5418
← Back to blog
November 16, 2026

Composite Shake vs CertainTeed Presidential TL: Where the Premium Asphalt Is Enough

Most homeowners who want the cedar look get shown two options a tier apart: a luxury triple-laminate asphalt shingle, or a molded composite shake. The gap in price is real and so is the gap in result. The honest answer depends on the house, not the product.

The two products, described fairly

CertainTeed Presidential TL is a luxury asphalt shingle built as a triple laminate, meaning three bonded layers rather than the two in a standard architectural shingle. CertainTeed describes it as its heaviest shingle, shaped and shadowed to imitate hand-split wood shake, and the company publishes a lifetime limited warranty for residential homeowners on defined terms. Composite shake, from manufacturers such as Brava and DaVinci, is a molded polymer tile taken from or modeled on real split cedar, generally rated Class 4 for impact under UL 2218, usually part of a Class A fire-rated assembly, with published 50-year limited warranties. Both are trying to deliver the same thing: a wood-shake appearance without wood. They land in different places, and they are not the same price.

Where the difference shows up, physically

A composite tile is a thick molded piece with real depth at the butt end, so each course casts a shadow the way a split cedar shake does. A triple-laminate asphalt shingle creates its shadow by layering and by the way the tabs are cut and colored, which is a very good illusion at distance and a less good one up close. The practical consequence is about viewing distance and sight lines. From the street, on a two-story house with a steep roof, Presidential TL reads as a shake roof to almost everyone. From a second-floor window of the house next door, from a balcony, from a driveway directly below a low eave, or along a rake edge at eye level on a gable, it reads as asphalt. Walk your own property and work out which views people actually have of your roof. That single exercise decides this more often than any other factor.

Weight, structure and the thing people assume wrongly

Presidential TL is among the heaviest asphalt shingles made, which homeowners sometimes hear as a structural concern. It is not. It installs on standard framing with standard decking like any other asphalt shingle. Composite shake is also light, typically a small fraction of natural slate, so neither of these two products raises the structural question that real slate can. Weight is simply not a deciding variable between these two. If someone tells you it is, ask them to be specific, because the real structural conversation belongs to natural slate and clay tile, which we cover on our slate roofing page.

Impact rating: confirm the SKU, do not assume the family

This is where quotes get sloppy. Manufacturers typically publish impact ratings product by product, and a luxury shingle line and that manufacturer's impact-rated line can carry similar names and look nearly identical in a brochure. Do not assume a premium asphalt shingle is Class 4 because it is expensive. Ask for the specific product name, the specific color, and the UL 2218 class in writing, and keep that documentation if you intend to pursue an insurance credit. Premium composite shake products generally do carry Class 4, which is a genuine advantage of the composite side of this comparison in a hail market. How much that is worth is in our Class 4 comparison.

Lifespan, and reading a warranty properly

A lifetime limited warranty on an asphalt shingle is not a promise of unlimited life. It is a defined term with a non-prorated period at the front and proration afterward, and in practice a luxury asphalt roof in this climate is a thirty year expectation managed well, not a fifty year one. A 50-year limited composite warranty is also prorated and also limited, but it sits on a material that does not have granules to lose or an asphalt mat to dry out. If you expect to own the house for fifteen or twenty more years, the asphalt roof will almost certainly outlast your ownership and the composite premium goes to the next owner. If this is the last roof you intend to buy, that calculus inverts. What each kind of warranty does and does not cover is on our warranties page.

Repairs, and the part nobody asks about

Something will eventually need to come off your roof: a satellite mount, a chimney rebuild, a failed pipe boot, a branch strike. Asphalt is easy here. Any competent crew can open it and close it, and matching material is available from any supply house in the area. Composite is less forgiving. The crew needs to know the fastening pattern and the course geometry, and matching tile means the right profile, the right width and the right color blend, which can mean a special order. Neither of these is a reason to choose or avoid either product. It is a reason to keep a bundle of spare material in the garage when you install composite, which we recommend on every composite job we do.

Where the board or the street settles it

On a street governed by an architectural review board or a covenant written around wood roofs, the question may not be yours to answer. Boards that once required real cedar increasingly accept a composite that reads convincingly as cedar from the street, and the same boards very often will not accept an asphalt shingle imitating shake, because the whole purpose of the covenant was to prevent exactly that. Ask the board before you choose, not after. We wrote about how that conversation actually goes in will the review board approve a synthetic roof.

Where Presidential TL is the better buy, plainly

On a house with no cedar or slate history, where the shake look is a preference rather than an architectural requirement, luxury asphalt is usually the smarter money. On a house in a neighborhood whose resale comparables are all asphalt roofs, the composite premium is unlikely to come back at sale, and we say so on estimates. On a shorter ownership horizon. Where the budget is real and the alternative to luxury asphalt is deferring the roof another two winters, which is a worse outcome than any material choice. And on roofs where most of the visible area is high and far from any sight line, because that is precisely where the asphalt illusion works best.

Where composite earns it

On a home whose architecture was designed around a wood roof, where an asphalt imitation will read as a compromise to anyone who knows the house. Where a review board requires wood or a convincing equivalent. Where the owner is tired of cedar maintenance and wants the look permanently rather than for one more cycle. Where hail history and insurability are pressing on the decision. Where the ownership horizon is long enough that a fifty year material is a real plan and not a slogan. And on shaded lots where real cedar grows moss and an asphalt roof under heavy tree cover will streak. Our broader cedar comparison is in cedar shake vs synthetic shake.

What drives the price on each

For standard and luxury asphalt work, replacement in this market runs roughly $15,000 to $40,000 depending on size, pitch, complexity, tear-off layers and deck condition, with larger or more complex homes running $40,000 to $70,000. A luxury triple-laminate shingle sits toward the upper part of that for a given house rather than in a different category. For premium composite we do not publish a job total, because the spread across these homes is too wide for a number to help anyone. What moves it is the profile and color blend, the square count and how cut up the roof is, the linear feet of hip and ridge and what product those pieces are, whether solid tile or metal goes at the valleys and rakes, and the flashing metal and gauge. We publish the delta against the base scope so you can see what the upgrade costs on your roof.

See both on a real roof

We will put both on the same proposal, as priced options with the delta shown, and we will drive you to an installed roof of each so you can judge them from the distance your neighbors actually see your house from. We have talked homeowners out of the composite upgrade and we have talked homeowners out of the asphalt one, and both conversations were the right call for those houses. Leaders Roofing is family-owned, working on roofs across the north and northwest suburbs since 1996, residential and commercial. Call 708-847-5418 or request a free estimate. See also our architectural vs designer shingles and our estate home roofing page.

Frequently asked questions

Is CertainTeed Presidential TL as good as a composite shake roof?

It is the best asphalt imitation of a wood shake roof and it costs substantially less than composite, but it is asphalt. From the street on a steep roof it reads as shake to almost everyone. Along a rake edge at eye level, from a neighboring second floor, or from directly below a low eave it reads as asphalt. Walk your property, work out which views people actually have of your roof, and decide from that.

Is Presidential TL impact rated?

Do not assume it based on price. Manufacturers publish impact ratings product by product, and a luxury line and an impact-rated line from the same company can carry similar names. Ask for the specific product, the specific color and the UL 2218 class in writing, and keep that documentation if you plan to pursue an insurance credit. Premium composite shake products generally do carry Class 4.

Will an HOA approve Presidential TL instead of cedar?

Frequently not, and this is the one factor that can take the decision out of your hands. A covenant written around wood roofs usually exists specifically to prevent asphalt imitations of wood. The same boards increasingly do accept a composite shake that reads convincingly as cedar from the street. Ask the board before you order anything, and bring a full-size sample plus the address of an installed roof nearby.

Which lasts longer, luxury asphalt or composite shake?

Composite, by a clear margin on paper: 50-year limited warranties on a material with no granules to shed and no asphalt mat to dry out, against a lifetime limited warranty that is prorated and realistically a thirty year expectation in this climate when maintained. Whether that matters depends on how long you intend to own the house. On a fifteen or twenty year horizon the asphalt roof outlasts your ownership and the premium goes to the next owner.

Let's talk about your roof.

No pressure, no obligation. Just a straight answer about what your property needs.

Request a Free Estimate Call 24/7 · (708) 847-5418
Call 24/7 · (708) 847-5418