About
Services
Roof Replacement Roof Repair Emergency Repair & Tarping Ice Dam Leak Repair Hail Damage Replacement Cedar Shake Slate Copper Roofing & Flashing Estate Home Roofing Commercial Roofing Flat Roofing Commercial Leak Repair Commercial Maintenance Roof Inspection Gutters & Siding Roof Coatings Gravel & Ballast Removal Sheet Metal & Flashing Church Roofing Why Choose Us Financing
Service Areas Our Work Blog Contact Careers · We're Hiring Polski / Po polsku
Get a Free Estimate Call 24/7 · (708) 847-5418
← Back to blog
November 17, 2026

DaVinci Roofing Price Comparison: How It Stacks Up Against Cedar, Slate, Brava and Asphalt

Homeowners comparing DaVinci usually want one thing: where it sits on price against the alternatives. Here is the honest ranking, and the list of things that move the number on your house.

The short answer

DaVinci composite shake and slate cost substantially more than architectural asphalt shingles, generally less than a natural slate roof once slate's weight and specialist labor are counted, and land in the same premium bracket as real cedar shake and Brava composite. Where your roof falls inside that bracket depends far more on the house, its complexity, deck, trim and flashing, than on the brand. We install DaVinci and Brava and quote them side by side, so the comparison below is the one we walk homeowners through. We do not publish a dollar figure for premium materials because any single number would be wrong for most homes reading it.

DaVinci vs architectural asphalt shingles

This is the biggest gap. Composite tile is a heavier, more expensive material with more trim pieces and more labor per square than an asphalt roof, so a DaVinci roof is a multiple of an asphalt roof on the same house. Owners choose it for the look of cedar or slate, a long limited warranty, and impact resistance, not to save money up front. If budget is the main driver, a premium architectural shingle is the right comparison; see architectural vs designer shingles.

DaVinci vs real cedar shake

Up-front, a quality cedar shake roof and a DaVinci composite shake roof are in the same range. The difference shows up over the life of the roof: cedar needs ventilation done right, periodic cleaning and treatment, and some North Shore insurers surcharge or decline it, while composite needs very little. That ongoing cost and the insurance question are why many owners replacing cedar move to composite. Our cedar shake vs DaVinci comparison goes through it in detail, and cedar roof insurance on the North Shore covers the insurance side.

DaVinci vs natural slate

Natural slate is usually the most expensive of the group. The stone itself costs more, it is several times heavier, which can mean structural review and reinforcement, and it needs crews who work slate regularly. DaVinci synthetic slate gives a similar look at a fraction of the weight and installs more like a conventional roof. On a restoration where the original slate is sound, repairing the slate can still beat replacing it; see slate roofing.

DaVinci vs Brava

These two are the composite tiles most often quoted against each other on Chicago-area estate homes, and on price they are close enough that the profile chosen and the house matter more than the brand. Color blends, trim options, warranty terms and how the product handles our freeze-thaw cycles are the real differences. We are a certified Brava Cedar Shake installer and also install DaVinci, so we can price both on the same estimate. See Brava vs DaVinci head to head and DaVinci vs Brava vs EcoStar.

What actually moves a DaVinci quote

How cut up the roof is: dormers, turrets, valleys and steep pitches mean more cutting and waste. Trim footage: hips, ridges, rakes and valleys are priced by the foot. What comes off and what is underneath: tear-off layers and, above all, the condition of the deck, since composite tile needs a flat, sound deck. Underlayment and ice protection at eaves and valleys. Flashing metal, steel or copper. Ventilation. And access, landscape protection, the permit and any HOA or architectural review. Every one of these should be its own line on a written estimate.

How to compare two DaVinci quotes

Line them up item by item: profile and blend, tear-off layers, sheathing allowance, underlayment coverage, flashing metal, ventilation, trim finish and who handles the permit and review board. A much lower quote is almost always missing one of these, or plans to price the deck after the old roof is already off. Ask whether the installer will put the DaVinci warranty paperwork in your name at the end of the job.

Get DaVinci and Brava priced side by side

Call (708) 847-5418 or request an estimate. We inspect the roof and attic, bring full-size samples, and give you a written, itemized estimate, with DaVinci and Brava on the same page if you are choosing between them. Leaders Roofing is family owned and operated, based in Mount Prospect since 1996. More on Brava and our estate home roofing.

Frequently asked questions

Is DaVinci roofing more expensive than cedar shake?

Up-front they are in a similar premium range. Composite usually costs less over the life of the roof because it needs far less maintenance, and it avoids the insurance surcharges some carriers put on cedar.

Is DaVinci cheaper than natural slate?

Usually, yes. Natural slate costs more as a material, weighs several times as much, and needs specialist crews; DaVinci synthetic slate gives a similar look at a fraction of the weight.

Is DaVinci or Brava cheaper?

They are close. The profile, color blend and the complexity of the house usually move the price more than the brand. We quote both on the same estimate so you can compare directly.

Why don't you publish a DaVinci price per square?

Because the per-square figure hides what actually moves a composite job: deck repair, trim footage, flashing metal and roof complexity. Two quotes with the same per-square price can describe very different roofs.

Let's talk about your roof.

No pressure, no obligation. Just a straight answer about what your property needs.

Request a Free Estimate Call 24/7 · (708) 847-5418
Call 24/7 · (708) 847-5418