Frost in the Attic in Winter: What It Means and How to Fix It
White frost on the nails and the underside of the roof boards is not a roof leak, but it turns into one in the first thaw. Here is what causes it and what fixes it.
What attic frost is
On a cold night, warm moist air from the house rises into the attic, meets the cold underside of the roof deck and the nail tips poking through it, and freezes there as frost. On the next sunny or mild day the frost melts all at once and drips onto the insulation and ceiling, which looks exactly like a roof leak. If you see water stains on the top-floor ceiling after a thaw with no rain, frost is one of the first things to check, along with ice dams.
The usual causes
Almost always it is one of four things. Bathroom or kitchen fans that vent into the attic instead of outdoors, or whose duct has come loose. Air leaks from the house into the attic around recessed lights, the attic hatch, plumbing and wiring holes, and chimney chases. Blocked or missing soffit vents, so the attic cannot trade moist air for dry outside air. And high indoor humidity from humidifiers, drying laundry indoors, or a tight house with too little ventilation.
Why it matters
A little frost on a very cold night is not unusual. Frost that builds up night after night soaks the insulation, which then stops insulating, and repeated wetting of the roof deck leads to mold, rusted nails and, eventually, soft or delaminated sheathing. It also points to the same heat loss that drives ice dams, so homes with attic frost usually have icicle and ice dam problems as well.
What fixes it
First, make sure every exhaust fan ducts all the way outside through a roof or wall cap, not into the soffit or the attic. Second, air-seal the attic floor: foam or caulk around penetrations, a weatherstripped and insulated hatch, and sealed chases. Third, check that soffit intake vents are open and not buried under insulation, with baffles at the eaves, and that there is matching exhaust at the ridge or roof vents. Fourth, keep indoor humidity reasonable in the coldest weather. Details on our attic ventilation and attic insulation pages.
What not to do
Do not add more roof vents without fixing the air leaks first; more exhaust can pull even more moist house air into the attic. Do not seal up the soffits to keep the cold out. And do not ignore wet insulation; once it is soaked and matted it needs to be dried or replaced.
When to call a roofer
Call if there is water on the ceiling, if the roof boards look dark, stained or soft, if there is visible mold, or if you are not sure whether you are looking at frost or a roof leak. We inspect the attic and the roof together and put the cause in writing. Call (708) 847-5418. Leaders Roofing is family owned and operated, based in Mount Prospect since 1996. See also our winter roof maintenance guide.
Frequently asked questions
Is frost in the attic normal in winter?
A light coating on the coldest nights can happen, but frost that builds up regularly is a sign that warm, moist air from the house is getting into the attic through air leaks or misrouted exhaust fans, and that the attic is not ventilating properly.
Can attic frost cause ceiling leaks?
Yes. When the frost melts on a sunny or mild day it drips onto the insulation and ceiling, leaving stains that look like a roof leak even though no water came through the roof.
How do you get rid of frost in the attic?
Vent bathroom and kitchen fans outdoors, air-seal the attic floor around lights, hatches and penetrations, make sure soffit and ridge ventilation are open and working, and keep indoor humidity reasonable during cold snaps.